Pick a Bagel Menu

Please Note

• Please Note - Special Instructions Adding to Orders will Not Be Honored -- Dear customers, all special instructions added to orders which change the nature of the item in question will not be honored, due to the difficulty of keeping track of these requests in a busy restaurant. An example of a special instruction that cannot be honored would be ordering a plain bagel, and then asking for us to make it a bacon egg and cheese bagel sandwich. Thank you.

Hot Breakfast

Served until 1pm.

• 1 Pancake, 1 Egg, 1 Sausage, 1 Bacon $4.95
• 2 Cinnamon Pancakes $2.95
• 2 Cinnamon Pancakes w/ 2 Eggs $4.95
• 2 Pancakes, 2 Eggs, 2 Sausage, 2 Bacon $7.95
• Two Eggs on a Bagel $2.95

Omelettes

Served with a bagel and home fries.

• Cheese Omelet $6.50 With your choice of cheese.
• Customer Specialty Omelet $6.50 Any 4 vegetables of your choice.
• Greek Omelet $6.50 With feta cheese, olives and tomatoes.
• L.E.O. Omelet $6.50 With lox, eggs and onions.
• Pick-A-Bagel Omelet $6.50 With eggs, parsley and onions.
• Spanish Omelet $6.50 With eggs, marinara sauce, tomatoes, onions and peppers.
• Vegetable Omelet $6.50 With mushrooms, peppers, tomatoes and broccoli.
• Western Omelet $6.50 With ham, peppers, onions and tomatoes.

Healthy Start

Served until 1pm.

• Freshly Sliced Seasonal Fruit $5.00
• Homemade Granola $3.50 With low-fat yogurt and fresh berries.
• Oatmeal $2.50

Muffins, Pastries & Desserts

• A Dozen Bagels (14) $13.20 Buy 12 bagels, but get 14. Please specify in the special instructions box below how many of each bagel you prefer.
• Assorted Small Cookies (1 lb.) $12.99
• Bagel $1.10
• Crumb Cake $2.95
• Cupcake $2.75
• Danish $2.75
• Fat-Free Muffin $2.75
• Filled Croissant $2.75
• Flat Bagel $1.50
• Jumbo Cookie $2.00
• Mini Bagel $0.75
• Mini Cupcake $0.95 Assorted.
• Mini Muffin $0.95
• Muffin $2.75 Assorted flavors.
• Plain Croissant $2.25
• Pound Cake $2.75
• Sugar-Free Muffin $2.75

Lunch Specials

Served Monday to Friday until 4 PM. Your choice of cold cut or combo sandwich with a side and a soda.

• Cold Cut Sandwich Lunch Special $7.50
• Panini Lunch Special $7.50

Homemade Soups

• Chicken Noodle Soup $4.50
• Soup of the Day $4.50 For the daily soup selection please call Pick a Bagel at 212-717-4668 and enter your choice in the special instruction box below.

Salads

We proudly serve Ellman`s salad dressings.

• Chef`s Salad $9.95 Roasted turkey, roast beef, hard boiled egg, Swiss cheese, American cheese all wrapped and sliced on a bed of lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers and onions.
• Chicken Salad Platter $8.95 With lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, olives and a choice of side salad.
• Create Your Own Salad $5.95 Bed of lettuce with your choice of 4 toppings.
• Tuna Salad Platter $8.95 With lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, olive and your choice of potato, macaroni or cole slaw.
• White Fish Salad Platter $8.95 With lettuce, tomato, onion, cucumber, olives and a choice of side salad.

Cream Cheese Sandwiches

• Buttered Bagel $1.50
• Cream Cheese Bagel $2.75

Sandwiches

Your favorite deli selections presented as sandwiches. We proudly serve Hellman`s Mayonnaise.

• BLT Sandwich $4.50
• Cheese Sandwich --
• Gourmet Food Sandwich --
• Meat Sandwich --
• Salad Sandwich --
• Smoked Fish Sandwich --

Combination Sandwiches

• #1 Combination Sandwich $9.95 With corned beef, pastrami, Swiss cheese and coleslaw.
• #2 Combination Sandwich $9.95 Grilled chicken, onions, oven roasted peppers, Mozzarella cheese and mustard.
• #3 Combination Sandwich $9.95 Roast beef, turkey, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing.
• #4 Combination Sandwich $9.95 Turkey, corned beef, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing and coleslaw.
• #5 Combination Sandwich $9.95 Reuben sandwich with corned beef, melted Swiss cheese, sauerkraut and mustard.
• #6 Combination Sandwich $9.95 Turkey, ham, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing and coleslaw.
• #7 Combination Sandwich $9.95 Italian hero with ham, provolone cheese, salami, lettuce and tomato.
• #8 Combination Sandwich $9.95 Turksy club with turkey, bacon, lettuce & tomato.

Panini

• Chicken Caprice Panini $7.50 Grilled chicken, plum tomatoes, fresh Mozzarella and arugula.
• Chicken Club Panini $7.50 Grilled chicken, smoked bacon, American cheese, plum tomatoes and house dressing.
• Chicken Fajita Panini $7.50 Grilled chicken, Cheddar cheese, roasted peppers, caramelized onions and salsa.
• Chicken Parmigiana Panini $7.50 Breaded chicken, marinara sauce, Parmesan cheese, fresh Mozzarella, endive and plum tomatoes.
• Italiano Panini $7.50 Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, fresh Mozzarella cheese and Russian dressing.
• Meatless Panini $7.50 Mozzarella cheese, plum tomatoes, basil, spinach and sun-dried tomato spread.
• Tuna Melt Panini $7.50 Albacore tuna, Cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato.

Knishes

• Kasha Knish $3.25
• Mushroom Knish $3.25
• Potato Knish $3.25
• Spinach Knish $3.25

Smoked Fish Platters

Served with lettuce, tomato, Bermuda onion, bagel and a side of plain or scallion cream cheese.

• Belly Lox Platter $13.50
• Nova Scotia Salmon Platter $13.50
• Smoked Fish Supreme Platter $21.95 With lake sturgeon, Nova Scotia lox and white fish.
• Smoked Sable Platter $13.95
• Smoked White Fish Platter $10.95
• Sturgeon & Belly Lox Platter $18.50
• Sturgeon & Nova Platter $18.50
• Sturgeon Platter $15.95

Salad Spreads By The Pound

• Baked Salmon Salad (1/4 lb.) $4.50
• Chicken Salad (1/4 lb.) $3.50
• Chopped Herring (1/4 lb.) $2.25
• Egg Salad (1/4 lb.) $2.25
• Low Fat Chicken Salad (1/4 lb.) $3.50
• Low Fat Egg White Salad (1/4 lb.) $2.50
• Low Fat Tuna Salad (1/4 lb.) $3.50
• Low Fat White Fish Salad (1/4 lb.) $4.50
• Smoked Tuna Salad (1/4 lb.) $3.50
• Tuna Salad (1/4 lb.) $3.50
• Vegetable Tuna Salad (1/4 lb.) $3.50 No mayo.
• White Fish Salad (1/4 lb.) $4.50

Cream Cheese Spreads By The Pound

• Low-Fat Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.50
• Low-Fat Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.75
• Low Fat Lox Spread (1/4 lb.) $3.25
• Low Fat Scallion Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.75
• Low Fat Vegetable Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.75
• Lox Spread (1/4 lb.) $3.50
• Olive Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.50
• Plain Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.25
• Scallion Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.50
• Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.75
• Tofu Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.50
• Tofu Lox (1/4 lb.) $3.75
• Vegetable Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.50
• Vegetable Tofu Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.75
• Walnuts & Raisins Cream Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.75

Smoked Fish By The Pound

• Belly Lox (1/4 lb.) $9.25
• Herring In Cream Sauce (1/4 lb.) $3.50
• Nova Scotia Salmon (1/4 lb.) $9.25
• Smoked Sable (1/4 lb.) $9.75
• Smoked White Fish (1/4 lb.) $5.50
• Sturgeon (1/4 lb.) $10.00

Meat By The Pound

• Boiled Ham (1/4 lb.) $3.25
• Bologna (1/4 lb.) $2.95
• Corned Beef (1/4 lb.) $4.50
• Fresh Roasted Turkey (1/4 lb.) $3.95
• Genoa Salami (1/4 lb.) $2.95
• Hard Salami (1/4 lb.) $2.95
• Honey Glazed Turkey (1/4 lb.) $3.95
• Kosher Salami (1/4 lb.) $3.25
• Pastrami (1/4 lb.) $4.50
• Roast Beef (1/4 lb.) $3.95
• Smoked Turkey (1/4 lb.) $3.95
• Turkey Breast (1/4 lb.) $3.95

Cheeses By The Pound

• Alpine Lace Swiss Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.95
• American Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.25
• Cheddar Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.95
• Mozzarella Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.95
• Muenster Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.50
• Provolone Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.50
• Swiss Cheese (1/4 lb.) $2.50

Gourmet Food By The Pound

• Avocado Salad (1/4 lb.) $2.50
• Breaded Chicken (1/4 lb.) $2.95
• Cole Slaw (1/4 lb.) $0.95
• Crab Cake (Each) $2.95
• Grilled Chicken (1/4 lb.) $2.95
• Israeli Salad (1/4 lb.) $2.25
• Macaroni Salad (1/4 lb.) $0.95
• Potato Salad (1/4 lb) $0.95
• Shrimp Salad (1/4 lb.) $3.95
• Tabouli Salad (1/4 lb.) $2.25
• Turkey Burger (Each) $2.95
• Veggie Burger (Each) $2.95

Beverages

• Arizona Iced Tea $2.25
• Bottled Water --
• Cappuccino --
• Coffee --
• Decaf Coffee --
• Flavored Coffee --
• Gatorade $2.50
• Half & Half $3.95
• Herbal Tea --
• Hot Chocolate --
• Iced Cappuccino --
• Iced Coffee --
• Iced Tea $2.50
• Lipton Tea --
• Milk --
• Seltzer Water (20 oz.) $1.95
• Snapple $2.25
• Soda Bottle $1.95
• Soda Can $1.25
• Tropicana Orange Juice $2.50
• Vitamin Water $2.50